Post by garywalker on Jan 7, 2011 20:25:36 GMT -5
On the surface it looked very clear: “Abstain from all appearance of evil” (1 Thess. 5:22). But as I looked at the context I realized that there was more to it than simply not doing something that someone might find questionable.
There is a book I read once by Joseph C. Aldrich entitled: “Life-Style Evangelism.” In it he addressed this very verse in a chapter called: “Avoid Evil Instead of Its Appearance.” He says the following:
In the Thessalonians passage quotes, Paul is talking about prophetic utterances in the previous verses (19-21). “Do not put out the Spirit’s fire; do not treat prophecies with contempt. Test everything. Hold on to the good. Avoid every kind of evil.” What is to be tested? The content (the message) of every prophetic utterance. What is good is to be held on to; what is evil is to be rejected. The passage is not saying never do something which looks like sin to another person. Jesus Christ frequently offended the leaders of the religious community.
Look at what the verse is saying in its context:
Quench not the Spirit. Despise not prophesyings. Prove all things; hold fast that which is good. Abstain from all appearance of evil. (1 Thess. 5:19-22)
In the text the Apostle Paul is telling them to allow prophetic revelations of the Spirit, test the utterances, keep what is good and abstain from those that appear bad. It is that simple. Paul is not telling them to avoid actions that might look bad to someone else as many say today.
So what do other Biblical Scholars and commentaries say?
Here are a few:
William Hendriksen says regarding verses 19-22:
The reason for this disparagement of prophetical utterance can readily be surmised. Wherever God plants wheat, Satan sows his tares….Paul, therefore, states what course of action the congregation should take: “Prophetic utterances do not despise, but test all things.”….Once a true verdict has been reached, the practical rule must apply: “to the good hold on; from every form of evil hold off.” [ii]
The Expositors Bible Commentary:
From Paul’s next prohibition, “Do not treat prophecies with contempt,” it appears that the Christians at Thessalonica like those at Corinth (1 Cor. 14:1) had underrated the gift of prophecy… Apparently, however, certain “idle” brothers (vs. 14; cf. 4:11,12) had misused this gift by falsifying data regarding the Lord’s return. This had soured the remainder of the flock against prophecy in general…Paul stipulates that all charismatic manifestations be tested with a view to accepting what is valid and disallowing what is not (vs.21, 21)…Allowance must also be made for professed spiritual manifestations that do not contribute but rather detract from the development of the local body…. “Hold fast” to the good, but “hold yourselves free from” every kind of evil that tries to parade as a genuine representation of the Spirit.” [iii]
Hogg and Vine state: “…but if, on being tested, the tongue, prophesying or teaching, was not approved, the saints were to turn away therefrom.” [iv]
And lastly, NT Greek Scholar A. T. Robertson in summary says: “Abstain from every from of evil…Evil had a way of showing itself even in the spiritual gifts including prophecy.” [v]
So why have Christians misused this passage? I think it is their failure to get the context. I know it was mine! Yet once the context is read we can see what Paul was saying and it isn’t that we avoid “questionable” behavior.
The problem with saying that Christians should avoid “questionable behavior” is that we have all kinds of opinions as to what is or is not questionable behavior. Obviously we are not talking about SIN or wrongs as described and given by God. We most definitely are to avoid disobeying God. But when it comes down to matters of Christian freedom and liberty then this misapplication of 1 Thess. 5:22 must be challenged. I might not like what you do but if it isn’t sin I should keep my mouth shut and allow you to enjoy your freedom in Christ. It is amusing to me, now that I’ve been a believer for 30 years, how many things I’ve seen be “evil” to one generation of believers are not to the next. I can remember when guitars (even acoustic) were said to have the appearance of evil. Drums were not allowed in church, then they became allowed in Sunday night services and now they are found in the morning service of every growing church! Were these things really evil? Not to God! The sad thing is that when today’s young Christians, who do things once taboo by the older generation, still find “the appearance of evil” in things that are pure and of no consequence to God.
So you might disagree with your fellow Christian who likes to dance, smoke cigars, has tattoos, enjoy a glass of wine or a beer for dinner, have piercings, or even drive a nice car (and “yes” I’ve heard this verse quoted in regards to the type of car one drives!) but you’ll not find God saying in this verse to avoid such liberties because they have the appearance of evil. The verse isn’t saying that!
Your actions and life choices are either EVIL or they are not. If what you do is evil then DON’T do it! If it isn’t then you have the freedom to do it or not, it is up to you – even if others think it “looks bad!” You may be misunderstood by the legalists but you’ll be in good company – Jesus looked bad to the religious people of His day.
To the pure, all things are pure, but to those who are corrupted and do not believe, nothing is pure. In fact, both their minds and consciences are corrupted. (Titus 1:15 NIV).
*******************************************
Aldrich, Joseph C. “Lifestyle Evangelism: crossing traditional boundaries to reach the unbelieving world” (Portland: Multnoma Press, 1981), 48. If you have not read or heard of this book I strongly encourage you to find a copy and read it. It will kick the “legalism” out of you and challenge you to look at the unbelieving world in a new light.
[ii] Hendriksen, William “New Testament Commentary, 1 & 2 Thessalonians” (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1975), 140.
[iii] Expositors Bible Commentary, Volume 11, Thomas, Robert L. “1 Thessalonians” (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Corporation, 1978), 292, 293.
[iv] Hogg, C. F. and Vine, W. E. “The Epistles of Paul the Apostle to the Thessalonians” (Glasgow: Pickering & Inglis, 1914), 200.
[v] Robertson, A. T. “Word Pictures in the New Testament – Vol. 4 The Epistles of Paul” (Nashville: Broadman Press, 1931), 38.
There is a book I read once by Joseph C. Aldrich entitled: “Life-Style Evangelism.” In it he addressed this very verse in a chapter called: “Avoid Evil Instead of Its Appearance.” He says the following:
In the Thessalonians passage quotes, Paul is talking about prophetic utterances in the previous verses (19-21). “Do not put out the Spirit’s fire; do not treat prophecies with contempt. Test everything. Hold on to the good. Avoid every kind of evil.” What is to be tested? The content (the message) of every prophetic utterance. What is good is to be held on to; what is evil is to be rejected. The passage is not saying never do something which looks like sin to another person. Jesus Christ frequently offended the leaders of the religious community.
Look at what the verse is saying in its context:
Quench not the Spirit. Despise not prophesyings. Prove all things; hold fast that which is good. Abstain from all appearance of evil. (1 Thess. 5:19-22)
In the text the Apostle Paul is telling them to allow prophetic revelations of the Spirit, test the utterances, keep what is good and abstain from those that appear bad. It is that simple. Paul is not telling them to avoid actions that might look bad to someone else as many say today.
So what do other Biblical Scholars and commentaries say?
Here are a few:
William Hendriksen says regarding verses 19-22:
The reason for this disparagement of prophetical utterance can readily be surmised. Wherever God plants wheat, Satan sows his tares….Paul, therefore, states what course of action the congregation should take: “Prophetic utterances do not despise, but test all things.”….Once a true verdict has been reached, the practical rule must apply: “to the good hold on; from every form of evil hold off.” [ii]
The Expositors Bible Commentary:
From Paul’s next prohibition, “Do not treat prophecies with contempt,” it appears that the Christians at Thessalonica like those at Corinth (1 Cor. 14:1) had underrated the gift of prophecy… Apparently, however, certain “idle” brothers (vs. 14; cf. 4:11,12) had misused this gift by falsifying data regarding the Lord’s return. This had soured the remainder of the flock against prophecy in general…Paul stipulates that all charismatic manifestations be tested with a view to accepting what is valid and disallowing what is not (vs.21, 21)…Allowance must also be made for professed spiritual manifestations that do not contribute but rather detract from the development of the local body…. “Hold fast” to the good, but “hold yourselves free from” every kind of evil that tries to parade as a genuine representation of the Spirit.” [iii]
Hogg and Vine state: “…but if, on being tested, the tongue, prophesying or teaching, was not approved, the saints were to turn away therefrom.” [iv]
And lastly, NT Greek Scholar A. T. Robertson in summary says: “Abstain from every from of evil…Evil had a way of showing itself even in the spiritual gifts including prophecy.” [v]
So why have Christians misused this passage? I think it is their failure to get the context. I know it was mine! Yet once the context is read we can see what Paul was saying and it isn’t that we avoid “questionable” behavior.
The problem with saying that Christians should avoid “questionable behavior” is that we have all kinds of opinions as to what is or is not questionable behavior. Obviously we are not talking about SIN or wrongs as described and given by God. We most definitely are to avoid disobeying God. But when it comes down to matters of Christian freedom and liberty then this misapplication of 1 Thess. 5:22 must be challenged. I might not like what you do but if it isn’t sin I should keep my mouth shut and allow you to enjoy your freedom in Christ. It is amusing to me, now that I’ve been a believer for 30 years, how many things I’ve seen be “evil” to one generation of believers are not to the next. I can remember when guitars (even acoustic) were said to have the appearance of evil. Drums were not allowed in church, then they became allowed in Sunday night services and now they are found in the morning service of every growing church! Were these things really evil? Not to God! The sad thing is that when today’s young Christians, who do things once taboo by the older generation, still find “the appearance of evil” in things that are pure and of no consequence to God.
So you might disagree with your fellow Christian who likes to dance, smoke cigars, has tattoos, enjoy a glass of wine or a beer for dinner, have piercings, or even drive a nice car (and “yes” I’ve heard this verse quoted in regards to the type of car one drives!) but you’ll not find God saying in this verse to avoid such liberties because they have the appearance of evil. The verse isn’t saying that!
Your actions and life choices are either EVIL or they are not. If what you do is evil then DON’T do it! If it isn’t then you have the freedom to do it or not, it is up to you – even if others think it “looks bad!” You may be misunderstood by the legalists but you’ll be in good company – Jesus looked bad to the religious people of His day.
To the pure, all things are pure, but to those who are corrupted and do not believe, nothing is pure. In fact, both their minds and consciences are corrupted. (Titus 1:15 NIV).
*******************************************
Aldrich, Joseph C. “Lifestyle Evangelism: crossing traditional boundaries to reach the unbelieving world” (Portland: Multnoma Press, 1981), 48. If you have not read or heard of this book I strongly encourage you to find a copy and read it. It will kick the “legalism” out of you and challenge you to look at the unbelieving world in a new light.
[ii] Hendriksen, William “New Testament Commentary, 1 & 2 Thessalonians” (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1975), 140.
[iii] Expositors Bible Commentary, Volume 11, Thomas, Robert L. “1 Thessalonians” (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Corporation, 1978), 292, 293.
[iv] Hogg, C. F. and Vine, W. E. “The Epistles of Paul the Apostle to the Thessalonians” (Glasgow: Pickering & Inglis, 1914), 200.
[v] Robertson, A. T. “Word Pictures in the New Testament – Vol. 4 The Epistles of Paul” (Nashville: Broadman Press, 1931), 38.